This little piggy went to market,
This little piggy stayed home.
This little piggy had roast beef,
This little piggy had none.
This little piggy went wee, wee, wee, wee, wee,
All the way home.
This is a rhyme I’ve known all of my life. I don’t remember when I first heard it, but I'm pretty sure I was barefoot at the time.
Now, my wife is sharing the same rhyme with our son.
As a youth, I accepted the words as truth, and never really broke them down for analysis. As a father, I think it’s wise to take a close look at the things my son hears.
This little piggy went to market,
This little piggy stayed home.
A piggy went to a market. That could certainly happen. I was just at a market yesterday, and I saw countless brands and cuts of bacon and other pork products. The rhyme is presented in a way where it sounds like the first little piggy (or the big toe) got the better deal, while the second piggy, who stayed home, got the short end of the stick. Based on my experience, I would think that a pig would be happy to stay home if the alternative was going to the market.
This little piggy had roast beef,
This little piggy had none.
Here’s where this composition gets weird in a hurry. What kind of pig eats roast beef?
I perused the internet, and here’s what I found (courtesy of the Alberta Pork Congress):
“For the first 3 to 4 weeks of life, piglets get milk from the sow. Then they are weaned, and for the rest of their life, pigs mostly eat cereal grains, such as corn, barley and soybean meal."
There is no mention of beef here. It goes on to say this:
"Wild pigs eat fungi, roots, tubers, bulbs, fruit, snails, earthworms, reptiles, eggs, young birds, small rodents and carrion."
That last bit supports the rhyme's premise that pigs can be carnivores. However, I don't think the pigs featured in the rhyme are wild. Wild pigs would be even less likely to shop in a market. Also, it is mentioned twice in the poem that these pigs have a home.
I could understand the "roast beef" part a little better if it was used out of necessity to rhyme with something like "toast thief" or "coastal reef". Not so. In this rhyme, "roast beef" comes out of nowhere. Any phrase could have been inserted, while still maintaining the beat and the flow of the nursery rhyme.
For example:
This little piggy went to market,
This little piggy stayed home.
This little piggy had chips and salsa,
This little piggy had none.
This little piggy went wee, wee, wee, wee, wee,
All the way home.
I've convinced myself that I need to speak to Mrs. Undaground about this. In our family, the third line of this famous rhyme will be different. I don't want our boy growing up thinking that on the food chain, pigs eat cows. That's ludicrous.
This little piggy went wee, wee, wee, wee, wee,
All the way home.
This fifth and final pig, the pinky toe, is clearly suffering mental anguish from the whole ordeal. Two of his closest pals, family members, sty mates (whatever they are) have gone berserk. One is pushing a shopping cart and the other is eating red meat (clearly a no-no among domestic pigs).
Any suggestions on how to make this poem more suitable for my son? We will consider any and all rewrites.